Waiting for the alarm to ring
Is this really happening? Not content with raiding Virginia Tech the eve of National Signing Day for this year's class, Coach James Franklin and staff appear to have poached SMU commit Elston Lane - yet another WR speed merchant to go alongside Batey and DeClouet and of course Brian "that guy's faster than Walt Flannigan's dog!" Kimbrow in next year's crop of freshmen.
If. Big if.
Because now we have to consider something that we may never have had to think about previously. We have thirteen kids who are technically in the fold...in July. It's a long way to February, and in between will be a football season. And that makes me uneasy.
See, despite the fact that he is already the single greatest recruiter to set foot on the Vandy campus, probably even including Dangerous Dan McGugin, James Franklin is still a first-time head coach in his first year at Vanderbilt. You have to go back twenty years to find a Vanderbilt head coach who delivered as many as five wins in his inaugural season, and Gerry DiNardo was coming from a stint as coordinator for co-national-champion Colorado. You have to go back to 1935 and Ray Morrison to find a new full-time Vandy coach who finished over .500 in a non-war year, and he basically inherited Dan McGugin's last team.
Now, I could be totally off the grid here. We could be in for the shock of a lifetime. But guys who take over a program mired in the dreck generally struggle that first year no matter how good they are. Jim Harbaugh - who just took Stanford, STANFORD FOR CRYING OUT LOUD to the Orange Bowl - won ONE (1) game his first season on the Farm. Hell, I don't think Nick Saban had a winning record his first year at Alabama, and it's a hell of a lot easier to win in Tuscaloosa than in the West End.
And this is not a terrible thing. It's not great, but it's not doom forever if we don't shock the world the first year out. Nobody will pronounce the James Franklin Experience a disaster if we finish up, say, 3-9.
But my question is: will we be able to keep thirteen guys in the fold through a 3-win season?
I'd like to think we can. CJF has apparently made much of telling everyone that nobody's spot on the depth chart is safe and everybody he brings could take somebody's job - and lose it to the next guy brought in. I think the 2011 new guys have to believe that a three-win season only makes it that much more likely they'll get a shot at an SEC starting job immediately. I'm sure that's what CJF is preaching, in any event.
This is all to day that while we're having a dream summer - a summer that is literally without parallel in our history as a sports-playing institution - there's a very real chance that autumn will wake us up like a ton of bricks through the window. If we get to Halloween with two wins, it's going to be tough to keep the faith. But if we steel ourselves now, and commit to pushing on through, we'll get there. Maybe not this year, maybe not even next year, but soon, this train is going to hit the rest of the league like...well, a freight train.
We just have to believe. And we have to hope that the new kids keep believing, too.
FanPosts are most often submitted by users. The views and opinions expressed in FanPosts do not necessarily reflect the views and opinions held by the editorial staff of The Anchor of Gold or SB Nation.
8 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Wow you actually wrote it
Well done. I agree on a lot of what you said; especially in terms of what his record will be next year. He’s got a really good chance to be the finest coach we’ve ever had but I agree, it won’t happen right away.
I currently star in the new MTV3 series,
"Jersey Shore: Lake Erie Edition"
Cleveland Rocks!
Read it and weep
Improvement > Record
I think it is more important that CJF’s team show improvement and be competitive. Maybe pulling off one we aren’t expected to win. My concern is that the excitement of the summer may make any improvement in coaching and competitiveness seem underachieving. I think he can keep most of them if we don’t get blown out in 10 games.
by Smoke n Mirrors on Jul 12, 2011 10:47 PM EDT reply actions
Agree with this
Last year was almost unwatchable. Not that I didn’t watch, but I often regretted if I did. It would be a big improvement if we can just be in ballgames, as in, not just hanging around (we did that a lot last year, but no one ever believed we were going to score the TD we needed to get us back in the game).
If we are hapless this year, yeah it could deflate things a bit. But the thing to me is, we are more talented than we played last year. I am by no means saying we should have been good, but we never should have been SOO bad.
If we can put together any offensive identity whatsoever, and keep the defense at least at the same level (when really, the defense should improve if we can find some guys to line up beside Marve) that would be huge.
The one thing we can’t have is CJF can’t flail. It’s one thing to be unsuccessful with a team no one expects to succeed. It’s another to look lost. But I think we’ll see improvement. I don’t know if it comes out in the record, but I think it’s entirely reasonable to believe we could win 3-4 games this season even without CJF working miracles.
The Saban thing is a good point
He technically finished 7-6 until they vacated 5 wins, but lost to Louisiana-Monroe. Crazy old Lou Holtz didn’t win a game in his first year at Carolina. Travelin’ Bobby Petrino went 5-7 in his first year at Arkansas, too.
This year is about learning a new system and likely playing a bunch of freshmen. As long as they beat Elon and Army, and the offense isn’t completely unwatchable, I’ll be satisfied. (I guess it’s awkward to say Vandy should beat a bowl team, but really, go look at Army’s schedule. They needed a TD in the final 40 seconds to beat Eastern Michigan.) Upsetting Ole Miss or Wake would be nice, but I’m strictly viewing that as a bonus.
What I worry about the most is keeping the student support up, because the turnout at the end of last year was depressing. The last thing Franklin needs is a bunch of recruits showing up for a late-season game, and being greeted by entire sections of empty seats.
That only occurred to me tangentially but I think it's hugely important
It may be easier to keep 13 guys on board than 5,000 students. Changing the culture around football would make more difference than just about anything. (But I also would really like to beat Wake and LOL Miss…)
"Well, if that ain't a show, I'll kiss your ass." - Gov. Jim Folsom Sr. (D-AL), 1948-52
by VandyImport on Jul 13, 2011 11:32 AM EDT up reply actions
If CJF can keep the 13 guys intact
He’s gonna start filling the student section back up. The culture shift starts from the coach down, and Franklin’s been awesome with that so far. We’ll see if he can sustain it, because goddamn those games were brutal to watch last year.
by Christian D'Andrea on Jul 13, 2011 11:35 AM EDT up reply actions
I agree
To take an example from across the country, Jeff Tedford’s best ever recruiting class came after his first ever losing season.
To keep ‘the 13’ CJF needs to remind them that what counts is how things look in 2015, not 2012. And though it could hardly be otherwise, Vandy is definitely trending upward.
Excitement and passion
Will keep the recruits and the students on board regardless of the # of wins. I recall some Maryland folks saying the Franklin was extremely emotional and fired up on the sidelines. His personality leads me to believe that he will go for exciting big plays with lots of aggressiveness on both Offense and defense. If we see that, I think we can move forward with these new recruits. And that aggression may very well lead to more wins than most predict.
By the end of last year, I thought we had lost control of the football program. The team had no continuity of coaches and they were without emotion to fight on. This year will be nothing like last year. Franklin is too smart and our returning players have too much pride for any flailing along. If students and recruits see the fight, determination, and excitement in our players and coaches, then they will match that passion.






















