The Official AOG VU FB Head Coach Rumormill
UPDATE - 2010.12.02 - 1.00 pm: Rivals.com's Tom Dienhart is reporting that Stanford's Greg Roman will interview for the Vanderbilt head coaching position on Friday (as in tomorrow). Here is Greg Roman's bio at Stanford's website. Here is Stanford's press release announcing his addition to their football staff.
The Goche had an excellent suggestion that AOG needed a centralized post dedicated to rumors regarding the head coaching search. This is that thread.
The stated goal of the search committee (personified by VC David Williams) was to have a candidate established and in place within three weeks. Posts are only eligible for comments for 30 days. IT'S A RACE AGAINST THE CLOCK!
Here's how this will work. If you hear a rumor regarding a candidate for the Vanderbilt Commodores Football Head Coaching Vacancy (VCFHCV), post it in the comments. Periodically, we'll vet those rumors as an update to this post.
Also, we've added this post to the "Featured Stories" section in the sidebar on the right, so you'll always be able to find it quickly, even if it slips down off the main page.
Let's see if we can do a better job than George Plaster...
110 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Ivin Jasper
Navy’s OC.
George Plaster threw this out there even before the Wake game had started. Pretty sure it’s bogus. We discussed it in either the Caldwell resignation post or the Wake gamethread.
Still sticking by my guns that they are only considering FBS Head Coaches at this point, with no coordinators/assistants other than Malzahn.
Lockeridge is on board with Clay Travis
He says here that Vandy never really considered Jasper and (as is clear now) Plaster’s talk about a Jasper hiring coming within 48 hours (>48 hours ago) was coming completely out of his ass.
So we have Lockeridge and Travis on the no-Jasper wagon, Low and Plaster on the Jasper wagon. Plus we’ve had the reports that we hadn’t even asked to talk to Jasper.
I’m going with Lockeridge and Travis and say I don’t think this is happening.
Is Miami our competition?
We need a countdown clock for the 30 days. It will be totally arbitrary, but it will make it feel more exciting.
I am disappointed with Randy Shannon being fired from Miami. (Partly because, having grown up an hour from Tallahassee, FSU was my first college football team and Randy Shannon’s teams were fun to play against… you know, because they sucked).
But moreso, I am disappointed as a Vandy fan because I think that they are the kind of school best suited to getting the kind of guy we might otherwise get.
The primary balance at Miami is the “Stanford of the South” image they want and the fact that they only time anyone cares about the school is when their football is good, and they tend to trive with the thuggy image.
(BTW, have they ever heard of Vandy, Duke, UNC? I mean seriously, Miami is maybe the Cornell of the South.)
Miami’s President Shalala wanted to keep Shannon because he was supposed to win without the thuglife. But they couldn’t after the USF loss and the beatdown FSU gave them and kind of sucky recruiting.
So will Shalala just let them get the biggest football name they can get? Or will they play up this 1A-1B approach to academics and football and try to get another school first guy, who is also a big football name.
So if they go for someone who values academics highly, that might be exactly the kind of guy who would be drawn to Vandy.
Plus, their football history probably trumps Vandy’s SEC-ness as a football draw.
Miami has some of our same problems. In the past, they have not necessarily had the cash to go after big name coaches. I’m afraid that these problems do put us into competition with them.
If that’s true, you have to think that their history and ability to recruit gives them an advantage over us.
But their fans (who couldn’t care less about their academics) are shooting for guys like Gruden.
Though that probably won’t happen, I hope that it shows that they want the biggest football name possible, whereas we want someone who has a system and fits our style.
In a related story, we do not want Randy Shannon, thanks.
BTW, Someone is going to get punched in the throat...
The next time I hear a UF fan who wants Malzahn say “Vandy can have Adazzio.”
Seriously just say “Vandy doesn’t give a shit, and no one cares about them anyway, so they can have our moron who no one wants. They’ll love it!”
I almost hope we get Gus more to piss off everyone else than because I’m convinced it’s the best option (because I have no clue).
Gus Malzahn
Numerous reports that Vandy has/had made multiple inquiries with Malzahn, who has politely declined. Not that I can blame him.
Has he declined altogether, or was that just because he’s still kind of busy? I get the feeling that he knows he will have plenty of opportunity even if he waits until January to take calls. But I also imagine he’ll get opportunities without having to resort to Vandy.
Yeah, I think declined altogether. He’s holding out for a big time job, seeing as how his stock is through the roof.
The only way I think he comes to Vandy is if he holds out long enough that the other school’s vacancies get filled while Vandy’s doesn’t, and then he gets word that the NCAA is coming down hard on Auburn and he pulls a Pete Carroll and jumps ship to the Commodores.
In other words, extremely unlikely.
by KingJamesIV on Nov 29, 2010 11:45 AM EST up reply actions
Al Golden
Temple’s Head Coach. The Nashville ABC affiliate WKRN last night mentioned he had expressed interest or something along those lines.
I like the idea of him
But probably just because he’s young. I guess it’s a bit of a bias, but I don’t expect anyone over 50 to really bring anything new to the table.
I’ve come to accept that we probably won’t get anyone proven unless we pull out a retread type, esp. since I don’t expect us to follow KJ4’s advice and get Leach. But Golden at least has success in all the headcoach experience he has and he has also coached at some big schools.
Really the only con I see on him is that he’s a defensive coach, and I always just viewed this as a chance to find someone innovative enough to get something out of our offense. But maybe we find our offensive innovator by uncovering some new OC, or maybe Golden has one he could bring with.
Tennessean puts Golden in the Mix
The Tennessean says that Golden is one of our choices for coach.
Good to hear, this is the kind of guy we have to check on. Not that we wouldn’t take a bigger name if he fell to us, but I appreciate that he is a head coach and I like that he’s young.
As much as we feel the need on offense, I could really appreciate his defensive success.
I was also interested that Hand and Kitchens are still recruiting. For one, just another reminder that they are and have been team players, but it makes me think they might stick around if the new coach asked, and I’d be happy to have both return. I’d especially be interested in them returning (with Hand as OC and Des back as RB coach) if we do get a defensive specialist like Golden.
The cons on Golden for me are: 1. the MAC really sucks recently, and it’s not like he’s totally dominating, (however, even in the MAC, Temple accomplishing anything is impressive) and 2. that his offense doesn’t seem great (77th in scoring offense).
According to Footballscoop.com Golden is no longer in the mix
Don’t know how reliable they are but it’s the first I’ve heard anything more, up or down, on Al Golden.
"Well, if that ain't a show, I'll kiss your ass." - Gov. Jim Folsom Sr. (D-AL), 1948-52
Supposedly he's out
According to both some some Fox dude and Joe Schad (ESPN Insiders only so I haven’t read it, but down the list on Nov. 30 at 1:26 PM).
Joe Schad also broke the story earlier this month that Robbie was working on a multi-year extension, so I guess it bears remembering that these are all just rumors.
Mike Leach
Unfortunately, not on the list despite taking Texas Tech to the BCS and having an IMPECCABLE historical APR and no shady recruiting issues.
Seriously, this guy is an unbelievable coach that Vandy, under normal circumstances, would never EVER have a chance to get. He would strike fear into the hearts of the other SEC coaches and their defensive coordinators.
Yet our BOT is scared off by his off the field baggage. Apparently they do not understand the concept of buy low, sell high.
What about a conditional hire based on him settling his pending lawsuits immediately?
Also, what if he wins both of his lawsuits. How does that change public perception of him? To his detractors, considering most of what you believe about him has come from ESPN’s coverage, how would him winning a defamation lawsuit (a longshot under normal situations, though Leach is a former lawyer).
Plus, his wikipedia page is AWESOME. Hey, he would certainly fit in the $2 mil / year category that Clay Travis tweeted VU was targeting for the position.
Ugh
How would him winning a defamation lawsuit against ESPN make you re-evaluate your understanding of what took place between him and Adam James?
by KingJamesIV on Nov 29, 2010 11:37 AM EST up reply actions
Mark Whipple
Depending on how things shake out at Miami, is starting to gain steam again, though it may be more related to how often his name popped up when CBJ first retired.
by Christian D'Andrea on Nov 29, 2010 11:44 AM EST reply actions
Resource
I don’t know how accurate it is but WWW.footballscoop.com is an interesting resource for the latest rumours.
by ATLVANDY on Nov 29, 2010 1:26 PM EST via mobile reply actions
Chris Low just said on the radio...
with Plaster (who is playing the, “I can’t tell you where I heard it but I didn’t just make it up card”), that Malzahn and Jasper are the two he’s really hearing so far. He wasn’t equivocal either, so it wasn’t one or the other, it was more just this is what I’ve heard so far.
I still think Plaster is full of it (I don’t listen to the radio here much so I don’t know what his bona fides are). Maybe Jasper is a legit possibility, maybe even the leader, but did he not say like, I don’t know 48 hours ago, that it would be Jasper within 48 hours. I think it’s still talking out of your ass if you hear a name as the leader and declare him hired.
But anyway, Low says that from what he’s heard Malzahn hasn’t said officially no yet, that he got the idea it was more not right now. That said, he still doesn’t think Malzahn ends up here.
He really didn’t have any new insight except that there is at least something to the Jasper rumor and Malzahn hopes are only mostly dead. He had no other names. But really it would shock/annoy me if we don’t seriously consider at least one person who has maybe, I don’t know, been a head coach somewhere before.
Threw the name out in the other thread...
…but Jerry Kill of Northern Illinois has the Huskies on 10-2 and headed to their third straight bowl. Not the kind of blockbuster hire I’d dream of, but it wouldn’t make me stick my head in a wood-chipper.
Don’t know about Golden but Temple appear headed to a bowl and they were an even bigger disaster area (I mean, dropped out of the BIG EAST??) so maybe the guy’s a turnaround artist.
Hell, is it worth throwing cash at whoever runs Connecticut? Ironic, given that they plowed us under this year, but to hire a coach off a BCS conference champ fresh off the Fiesta Bowl (or whatever) would be a coup…
"Well, if that ain't a show, I'll kiss your ass." - Gov. Jim Folsom Sr. (D-AL), 1948-52
Would Kill be a health risk? He had cancer before and was hospitalized again this year I think. He’s the kind of guy I would take a flyer on, at least he’s got D-I experience and he hasn’t failed yet.
I mentioned Dirk Koetter on the other thread, but he would be despressing, I don’t think anyone was thinking of a guy who was 21-28 in the Pac 10 in 6 years at Arizona St. (P.S., there’s another disappointing hire from Boise St. along with Hawkins, wonder if schools will consider this before running at Petersen.).
Edsall is at UConn, and currently overrated
Getting a lot of love for being (likely) BCS-bound…but he’s still coaching a mediocre team in a weak division. He’s nice enough, but I don’t think he’d get it done at Vandy.
by Christian D'Andrea on Nov 29, 2010 8:13 PM EST up reply actions
I don't think he would come anyway
He turned down Georgia Tech before they got Paul Johnson. At the time I was under the impression he would stay there for good, but maybe his opinion has changed.
Al Golden and Bud Foster
Allegedly VC DW is waiting to talk to both until after their games on Saturday.
Also, Rivals is reporting interest in David Lee (Dolphins QB coach), Tommy Bowden, and former Southern Miss coach Jeff Bower
David Lee
is a former Vanderbilt QB from the 70’s.
by KingJamesIV on Nov 29, 2010 10:33 PM EST up reply actions
also
was a QB coach at Vandy in said 70’s (presumably a few years after he graduated).
by KingJamesIV on Nov 29, 2010 10:34 PM EST up reply actions
Bud Foster at Va. Tech
Their D-Coordinator. Fits the Vandy profile, but his recruiting and who we’d add as an OC (Herb Hand?) would be lingering questions.
by Christian D'Andrea on Nov 30, 2010 11:42 AM EST up reply actions
I lived in SW Va for the year before I came to Vandy
As such, I hated VT b/c everyone else loved them (and I liked FSU). In that respect, getting Foster from them would be pretty awesome. Stupid Hokies.
As far as coordinators go (especially defensive) he certainly seems near the top of the could-be-a-head-coach list.
These defensive guys just scare me. I can’t handle any more 4th quarters starting with us down 7-0 knowing we should be able to win but probably won’t.
I know it’s kind of like a 3-13 NFL team drafting for “need” when they should just take the best talent but I don’t see how we can succeed against SEC defenses without some amount of innovation.
If we get someone who isn’t an offensive guru, he’d better have a good idea who he intends to get to handle that.
Bud Foster Speaks
"I haven’t gotten a phone call yet," he said. "I’m just focusing on hopefully beating Florida State."
Even if the Commodores did come calling, Foster would have a tough choice to make. He’s often said that he will only leave the Hokies for an ideal head-coaching gig and a situation that’s conducive to success.
Foster has called certain jobs "coach killers." So is Vandy one of those? "I know Tennessee’s a tough state to recruit in. We’ve been there before. And it’s in a tough conference."
But would Foster dismiss the gig if the Commodores wanted to talk?
"No," he said. "You’re seeing schools like Northwestern and Stanford and programs like that (succeed). I think at academic institutions, you can get a good, quality kid in there."
Not to mention, the thing that makes Vandy a tough job also makes it appealing.
"It’s an SEC school, in a BCS conference," Foster said. "It would be very intriguing from that standpoint if it ever happened. Can’t speculate on things that aren’t there."
Read the whole thing here
Vandy needs to turn up the heat on him
But mostly just to distract him from the FSU game.
I hope Foster is the target of Plaster’s next completely bullcrap story.
There really isn't a good reason not to interview him
I know everyone wants an experienced coach, but Bud Foster has serious name recognition for an assistant. He is a proven quantity as a DC and obviously has been loyal to that program.
Has he been there from the begining of the Beamer era? Just curious if he was part of the huge rebuilding effort that went on there.
Answer...yes
It appears Beamer was hired in 87 and brought Foster in as the linebackers and special team coach that year. He became the DC in 1995.
Might as well kick the tires
On Mark Stoops. It’ll never happen, he’s sitting pretty at FSU and will get a big job when he leaves. Plus he’s one year from going to the top of everyone’s hot coordinator lists.
Everyone who follows FSU (as I do as well) has pretty much accepted that Stoops is gone probably by the end of next year, I figure, if he’s going to bolt, he should bolt to Vandy.
But that will never happen, and I count myself in the get an offensive coach camp anyway. The way I see it, if we still suck but have a good offense, it’s way more fun than having an awful offense but a good defense.
Bite your tongue!
Mark Stoops if fine right where he is!!!!!!!!!
Does anyone know if George O’Leary from UCF is on the list. He was successful at GT and is doing a good job at UCF. In the baggage department, there is Jim Leavitt, the former University of South Florida coach. He would definitely bring a high level of energy to the program. Lastly, Mario Cristobal from Florida International. Not as big a name as the other two, but he doing a solid job and for the first time, they are going to a bowl. The thing that all three have in common is they are hard working and are very good recruiters.
Greg Roman - Stanford Assistant
13 years NFL coaching experience. Past couple years at Stanford. He’s a Broyle’s finalist (top assistant coach)… Seems like someone Vandy would target.
Seems Rivals is Wrong on this one
Doesn’t seem they have been right that often anyway.
Tennessean today quoted an email from Roman (on the record quotes make things much easier) saying that he hadn’t heard from us yet (though it doesn’t necessarily mean his people haven’t). He did say though:
“I would find it very interesting however, because of my experience bringing another academic institution to the top of the BCS football world. Vandy is very similar to Stanford!”
I like to think that this was a copy and paste from the email with the exclamation point original. It would be irresponsible journalism if they added the exclamation point (though not as irresponsible as letting Biddle near a keyboard).
But I do love that exclamation point, if Roman typed it, for so many reasons. Makes it seem he’s legit excited for us and just legitimately excited about coaching and I’d generally love some exclamation point-type energy from our new coach.
Other stuff in the article is basically a retread of the previously quoted stuff from Bud Foster, and another candidate we haven’t talked about much because it makes us (or me at least) want to puke. See new thread below.
by The Goche on Dec 3, 2010 1:29 AM EST up reply actions 1 recs
Tennessean
I think it was posted online yesterday. Not sure about the print edition. I know I read that before I heard about the Rivals report.
I take that back
I think Lockeridge did run a blog post, but may have taken down the one you mentioned earlier…
I can’t find it on the site, at least
First Real Concrete News of the Whole Search
According toLockridge Article from 12/4, Rivals report about Roman interviewing Friday was right.
Greg Roman did in fact interview on Friday (I guess the Tennessean thing I posted was old, even though the dateline was Friday). Roman apparently did quite well and apparently will probably be a finalist.
That kind of news is worthy of a story update (I’ll let you handle that KJ4, don’t want to run up on your byline).
Might be cool to have a list up there of confirmed interviewees.
Any way, I do like this a lot. He sounds like class act and I love the kind of points he’s putting up in Stanford.
As I have mentioned, I have a belief in Roman that is almost entirely unfounded by any actual knowledge of him.
I wouldn't know what to think
Hasn’t been a head coach or really even a coordinator (unless this “Associate Head Coach/Assistant Head Coach Offense/Tight Ends/Offensive Tackles” means he is the OC this year).
He better have his assistants line up as part of the sales pitch, because I would really need to be reassured to feel good about this.
Having looked down the wrong end of Stanford for two years...
…I can say without hesitation that they’ve been expertly coached up on the offensive side, and the reason you even know who Gerhardt or Luck are is because they do great work with the O-line. It’s still not my ideal preference to hire a coordinator, but this guy looks like the one to get if Malzahn isn’t a palatable option.
"Well, if that ain't a show, I'll kiss your ass." - Gov. Jim Folsom Sr. (D-AL), 1948-52
I would be nervous with a quasi-OC
But I do for some reason feel really good about him. I believe that, more than anyone else on the list, he could be the star that we catch on its way up.
I would still much rather Leach because I would rather be able to get a star who’s reputation (for his talent if not otherwise) is already at the top.
I have no reason to really think Roman is going to be any better than any other up-and-comer, but for some reason I do feel that way.
I’m not even sure that he’s a not a better candidate than Malzahn (though I would certainly still take Malzahn first).
Tommy Bowden
Has been mentioned several times by The Tennessean. Seems like some of the most BCS HC experience we have on the list. I’d bet we definitely consider him.
He did a solid job at Clemson, but honestly it just tempers my expectations when we’re talking about a guy who generally won 4 to 6 games a year, in the ACC, with better recruiting than Vandy.
That said, his teams sure did seem tough on FSU all those years.
I’m still not sure he’s what we want.
I mean, he would be a legit coach, and I’d feel better with him than I do lately. I could believe he could get us to a bowl once in a while, but I’m not sure that he is really a culture changer.
But I guess you could say, our culture is a culture of being illegitimate in the SEC, and if he’s legit that’s change enough. Still, even though it’s better than we are now, I don’t think anyone here would be happy with us just becoming like Kentucky is now.
I guess this goes to the main question: do we go with more experience but not much upside, or do we go with a head coach with less D-I experience, riskier, but someone you could believe has a higher ceiling than just looking legit?
That last point just reminds me how much I’d rather go for it and get Leach. We actually have an opportunity to get someone established who also has a high ceiling. GO FOR IT!
No Leach!!
He locked an ESPN analyst’s son in the closet. Would you do that??? What an idiot. All he worked for, down the drain.
OC?
So, if we do get a defensive minded guy as head coach, like Golden or Bud Foster, who might we consider for OC?
I don’t think we’d be really interested in Golden’s OC from Temple coming along (with his 77th ranked scoring offense), and obviously Foster wouldn’t have anyone to bring with him.
If we don’t get a guru for the HC, we almost certainly won’t get anyone established as OC either. So what are our options?
Make Hand OC, which seems like a solid option.
Maybe we could convince someone like Whipple to come. He was OC at Miami and got fired, so I mean he’s not exactly a hot commodity with lots of other offers. But I’d bet he’s only interested here if we offer HC.
But I’d bet if he doesn’t get a HC job or a big OC job he’ll just go coach a position in the NFL or something.
Otherwise, I think this might be the position that we try to innovate at. We grab an OC from a smaller school, or a good position coach from a big school. Maybe even a really hot high school head coach.
I realize this seems like looking too far ahead, but I think the administration when they consider a defensive minded guys have to have this in their heads, and that would have to be the biggest question for any of these guys in an interview.
David Lee!!! Former Vandy QB and current QB coach for the dolphins
I would love to get Randy Shannon as HC and let David Lee be the assistant HC/ offensive coordinator. Check David Lee out. I love what he has done with the wild cat and he can develop a QB and limit turnovers.
Remember, not long ago, Randy Shannon was one of the hottest defensive coordinators around. If you combine that with David Lee, you could have a solid foundation for offense and defense.
NYT Article with Hand was interesting
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/12/06/sports/ncaafootball/06colleges.html?_r=2&ref=sports
Interviews Hand about Malzahn and Kelly, who he is close with. I had three thoughts:
1. We’d better have a real offensive genius lined up as HC if we don’t keep Hand. If we hire a DC, I’m going to be disappointed if he doesn’t keep Hand. Also, if we hire a spread-minded OC as HC, I can’t think of a better option to run his offense for him.
2. Malzahn sounds like some sort of football savant. It sounds like he’s got Aspergers or something. He could be an awesome business minded HC (though it sounds like it won’t be for us). But it makes you wonder how he’d be recruiting when he literally told Hand that he doesn’t understand the concept of jokes. Not that I wouldn’t hire him real quick if he actually was interested.
3. How much would a no-huddle spread offense fit our program anyway? I know I might be biased against it after seeing it run so poorly for the 2 years I’ve been here. But even if we run it well, will we still see a version of the same problems we’re seeing now. How well would we have to run the no-huddle spread to keep the TOP from being so lopsided that it kills our defense?
I mean, even Oregon is 104 in TOP. But they also have really awesome athletes, and running it fast works if you score so many points no one can catch you. Against SEC defenses, with the athletes we can get, can we run it well enough that our defense can hang? That scares me.
In that way, as much as I love the idea of Hand, you wonder if we might be better off with Roman, whose offense in Stanford leads the country in TOP. Seems like if Roman is the guy, Hand would not be a fit at OC, which would be sad, but it seems like, with the athleticism deficit we usually have, TOP is our best friend.
If you are free this afternoon
Athletic Chancellor David Williams is supposed to be on 3 Hour Lunch at 1:30 on 104.5 The [Vol] Zone.
I’ll post anything interesting he says.
Not going to get much detail, but we've got some general specifics
The search firm is still narrowing down, but it sounds like the school hasn’t asked for a finalists list yet.
The search firm is contacting agents right now, and agents are contacting DW, but it doesn’t sound like they are really in discussions with any certain coaches.
He says he would possibly be willing to wait until after bowls for someone, but it sounds like he wants to get it done sooner rather than later, and it gives you the feeling that he wouldn’t want to hold on for a maybe.
Everything is so general you really can’t get too much from it and definitely no names, but it does sound like they are relatively early in the process.
I do get the idea that they’ll try to talk to Gus after the SECCG, but I doubt that if he wants to hold out until after the bowls before he even starts discussing that we’d wait that long on just hope.
Basically called out Plaster
Said we haven’t talked to a single coach face to face yet and that any other reports has been flat out wrong.
Says according to media “by Sunday morning we had hired 4 coaches.”
Here is the link to the interview
Yeah, I totally know how to work links.
One last interesting thing, when asked about the timing of the Robbie firing, he said it was in part so that they could let the kids know rather than them hearing in the media.
But he also said that they had guys that they wanted to contact right away and he didn’t want to contact guys until the spot was open.
Specifically he said 2 spots were open and 2 others were about to open and he believed that one school was prepared to offer someone and they wanted to make sure that the coach knew we were going to be open before he accepted that offer.
I guess that could that have been McCarney from UF to UNo.Tex. or it could have been someone who didn’t accept the offer. Interesting though.
Says we plan to be "competitive" financially
Says he’s paying to a “performance guage,” kind of sounds like he’s paying based on how much he expects.
Says Vandy uses performance incentives in their contracts, so we won’t be giving out a “$4 million” guaranteed contract, but that (while he does say no one is going to be making $4 mill with incentives either) that “you won’t go broke coaching Vanderbilt.”
If we want Chris Ault...
We’d better get to work… sign the petition: http://firechrisault.blogspot.com/
39 dissatisfied customers are already ready to pass Chris Ault along to us. They’re ready for bigger and better things. Well actually 38 people are ready, and one guy signed the petition to say he liked Chris Ault and wanted him to stay at Nevada. (That guy was named “Jim Cooper.” Thanks a lot Congressman!).
So sign away, and try not to mention that we will hire him as soon as they fire him.
Coincidentally, no signatures on the petition in a few days…Odd how that happens. I still think there is something better out there for Nevada, don’t stand for second best!
(P.S. someone other than Jim Cooper needs to tell Nevada fans to grow up and enjoy it because it’s not getting any better.)
Kevin Sumlin
How about Kevin Sumlin from University of Houston?
Runs the spread offense, protege of Stoops, expert at getting the most out of inferior talent. He brought UH back to the national stage by winning C-USA in his second season. UT had him as a candidate last season before he signed an extension (buyout would be needed).
Houston is also a huge spot for Vandy alumni (probably fourth behind nashville, atlanta, and d.c.) I mention this only to mean that he wouldn’t be unknown to a large Vandy contingent. He’s also a minority, which doesn’t hurt.
Re: Sumlin
Totally agree. I mentioned him on another post a couple days ago. Also a young guy which I think is a good idea. Look around the country and you see the successful coaches getting younger and younger. Vandy would also be a step up for him even though some sources have already said he is not interested.
We've supposedly set up 6-8 interviews
Says this site.
My choices based in no way on reality: Leach, Malzahn, Roman, (Whipple, Golden, Lee) Foster and Bowden.
Those are basically in my current order of preference, except that Whipple, Golden and Lee are in no particular order and I have no idea where to put Bowden. Probably ahead of those three though.
I’m liking Roman a lot lately. Of course, if Harbaugh is going to bolt to Michigan, he will have a good shot to stay at Stanford as HC.
I’d probably put Sumlin right after Roman but I haven’t heard his name anywhere on our end, and it sounds like he’s only interested in established programs.
I also am fine with Whipple after looking at Miami’s stats this season. His rushing offense was pretty good, even while his QB fell apart mentally and physically. And they still were in the middle in passing offense. Harris was overrated, but he also played terrible, so it does give me a little pause about QB development. Generally, I wouldn’t really want him to bring anyone from Miami with him either.
Blast from the Past
Before we made ICRC CRC, there seemed to be almost a consensus that everyone loved Ken Niumatalolo, I guess that has cooled this time around (maybe because of this).
I haven’t really heard his name anywhere. Wonder if his name might pop up at some point though.
Yuck...Randy Shannon
DO NOT WANT!
I said that immediately when he was fired (last line).
But Lockridge in the Tennessean cites a source that says Shannon is on our “desirable candidates” list.
PUKE!
So we really want a guy that was just at a supposedly similar academic program, only one that can recruit like nobody’s business and did for his first several years, and despite having top recruiting classes for the last few years, epically busted (even while some people suggested, ridiculously though it was, that they were a Top 10 team).
If Randy Shannon can’t get Miami about 7-5 in the ACC, what’s he going to do at Vandy in the SEC? No freakin’ thanks.
This might be for me the least desirable candidate I’ve heard yet.
Ugh, just ugh
Vandy alumni are campaigning for Randy Shannon.
I just don’t get it. All I know (and I’m sure Nolegrad89 would agree) is that FSU fans were disappointed when Randy Shannon was fired.
And yes, he has recruiting skill, but he was also recruiting at Miami, which is not exactly a 1:1 correlation with recruiting at Vanderbilt. When he was fired this week, he had all of six recruits, 3 4* and 3 3*, and he was struggling to hold on to those 6.
The reason: his teams always underachieved. He couldn’t get the best out of top quality recruits, what will he do with the guys he can get to come to Vandy, and in the SEC no less. He did have some big wins, but his teams collapsed like nobodies business.
If we do hire Shannon, sure he may bring in our first 4*, or maybe even a couple. But even if he does recruit well, even if he does pull off a nice upset or two, if we’re 5-5 with two games left, I just don’t see much reason to think that we don’t finish 5-7, and quite frankly we can’t afford to leave wins on the table.
I think we could expect Shannon to do exactly what he did at Miami: tease fans with improvement, and fail to deliver. If we want things to be like they’ve always been, Randy is our guy.
I agree
The only thing that would make sense to me is if this show that Vandy is interviewing minority candidates as well. There is so much wrong with Randy Shannon as a head coach. He is not very vocal on the sidelines. Sometimes I think someone should stick a mirror under his nose just to make sure he is breathing. When he talks to the media, he often says the wrong things. The only positive I can think of is his ties to South Florida recruiting, but other than his 2008 class, he has not done that well.
There are so many better candidates than Randy Shannon. I am not sure I would put him in a top 10 of choices.
We need Randy Shannon as HC and David Lee as Assistant HC/Off. Coord
I sent David Williams this email.
First of all, I want to thank you for the great job you have done. You don’t get enough respect. I am so tired of Climer and Biddle.
I wanted to give you my support for Randy Shannon. Most importantly, I think he embodies the goals of Vanderbilt. I respect him as a person and a coach. I think he would be an outstanding recruiter, coach and representative for our football team. I know that he appreciates loyalty, and I know that Vandy can be a very loyal place for successful coaches. He could be a great fit.
I really would love to see Vandy bring in Randy Shannon as Head Coach and David Lee as Assistant Head Coach/Offensive Coordinator. David Lee obviously has great Vanderbilt ties and would be a great developer of talent at the QB position for Vandy. He has done very well as the QB coach with the Dolphins. He knows how to limit turnovers and develop smart QB play.
This could be an incredible combination for Vandy, Shannon’s defensive ability and recruiting ability combined with David Lee offensive expertise, Vandy ties and QB development. I know the fan base and alumni could all support these two coaches. They really bring the best of both worlds with their experience on both side of the ball.
Please no Malzahn and Leach
Malzahn was a high school coach a few years ago and all of a sudden he is lucky enough to coach Cam Newton and he is the next big thing? You can’t coach a lot of the plays that Newton makes…. I’m not saying that Malzahn is a bad coach. But he is still unproven. He did well at Tulsa, but a lot of coaches have put up big numbers at small schools and conferences. I like Roman more than Malzahn. At least he has more experience. But I would prefer a head coach.
Leach locked a player in a closet. And I believe he still has a pending law suit. Vandy doesn’t need that. Please don’t forget that this was any player. He locked an ESPN analyst son in the closet…. what was he thinking???? wow.
You should
read this. He didn’t lock the kid in the closet. That was what Craig James told ESPN to report because he wanted Mike Leach fired for not playing his son.
And when you are done reading
listen here. Mike Leach did an interview on a local station down here in Miami. He is really lobbying for the UM job, but they are not interested. He has offered and will offer to any University, access to all depositions and other documents related to his case. The school can make up its own mind then with facts as to whether or not there is a basis for Craig James’ claim. In his 10 years at Texas Tech he went to more bowl games and his team’s graduation rate was higher than any other in school history.
The guy knows south florida high schools (he is currently living in Key West), which would help in recruiting. He stays involved in college football (he has a radio show on Sirius) and he really wants to get back into coaching.
I was not a huge fan of Mike Leach when he was at Texas Tech, but it is hard to deny his success. As he says he had the nations top offense year after year with lesser talented players. His offensive style and his personality would bring the attention to Vanderbilt that it needs in order to become relevant in the SEC. Try to imagine the buzz around campus when all these national media outlets are around to do interviews. Spring Practice would now become an event.
I live in Miami and have watched Randy Shannon for many years (played against him in high school) and he is a very nice, good, honest, decent man. But unfortunately he is not a successful head football coach. I do not think he is a good defensive coordinator either. If Vanderbilt wanted JUST a nice, decent, good honest man as its football coach, Robbie Caldwell would still be here.
I am not even sure if Mike Leach would be interested in the Vanderbilt job, but it would be a shame if nobody even asked him. Somebody call the radio stations in Nashville have them get on the phone and get this guy interviewed!!
On one of the message boards...
a VU fan called in to his radio show and asked him point blank. He said he loved Nashville and was impressed by our training table. Doesn’t sound like he’d completely oppose coming, but he also said he hadn’t heard from anyone (which isn’t surprising).
leach & gill
I would kind of like to see Leach at Vandy just for the Vince Gill comparisons!
Air Force' s Calhoun just added to list
Wow, I’m impressed with the names Williams is supposed looking at. They all seem to be great candidates. This is getting exciting. This VU search process and the potential candidates are so much better than what happened to our dear friends to the east.Go Dores!
A crap load of names
Lockridge had a nice big data dump in his latest.
In addition to his info on Roman’s interview (see the Roman thread), he was dropping previously unheard names like nobody’s business.
WisÂconÂsin defenÂsive coorÂdiÂnaÂtor Dave DoeÂren
Tulsa head coach Todd Graham
WisÂconÂsin offenÂsive coorÂdiÂnaÂtor Paul Chryst (2010 BroyÂles finaÂlist)
MichiÂgan State offenÂsive coorÂdiÂnaÂtor Don TreadÂwell
Nothing substantial about any of those guys, he just listed them (and a lot of previously heard names) as linked to the opening “by either speculation or fact.” Not the most exacting standard, but we’ll see if any of them show up again.
Todd Graham
That at least sounds like we might get Hand to stick around, which I wouldn’t mind in the slightest…especially with a coach that has worked with him before.
Hey guys, just saying Bruce Feldman tweeted these:
Hearing Maryland assistant James Franklin is in consideration for the Vandy job.
and
Hearing that Nebraska assistant Shawn Watson is slated to interview for the Vandy job on Sunday.
Some more names to add to your list
Purple Crush for best kicker in the NFL
Tommy Bowden is said to want the vanderbilt job.
Former Clemson and Tulane Coach Tommy Bowden is said to want the Vanderbilt job. He is currently living in Panama City, Fla., thanks in large part to a sweet parting gift from Clemson.
Whats weird, is where I found this. It was in an article by the Tennessean about Drew Brees being sportsman of the year.
http://www.tennessean.com/article/20101205/COLUMNIST0201/12050322/2072/SPORTS
Shawn Watson
nebraska’s current OC, how do u guys feel about him? i wouldnt say he is a “fan favorite” among the cornhusker fans, just a fair warning
I don't know much about him.
I need to put a table together of all these names. Maybe I’ll get to that tonight.
We have had a rash of OC names lately
And some of them, while I certainly don’t know much about the coaches themselves, don’t sound altogether exciting.
I mean if you can get a guy with no head coach experience, who’s got experience at a powerhouse like Maryland, and whose offenses have been ranked 92, 98 and 40 over the last 3 years, you jump on it, right?
Obviously, that was referring to Franklin.
Watson has actually done somewhat well in Nebraska. Scoring offenses ranked 28, 17, 75 and 28. Nebraska’s total offense under him has been ranked 9, 12, 99, 35. So other than last year, his teams have done well.
I kind of hope we don’t get him, but mostly because I found Bleacher Report articles both last year and this year begging that the guy get fired. It’s not that I think he’s a bad coach because people on Bleacher Report don’t like him. It’s more that I want them to keep him to annoy the Bleacher Report people calling for the #28 scoring OC in the country to get fired.
He probably shouldn't be on the short list...
Husker fan / Vandy alum here. Nebraska fans aren’t too high on Watson right now after some rather questionable play calling late in the Big 12 championship game and too many late season performances reminiscent of last year’s anemic offense. His offenses have their moments where they explode and put up gaudy numbers, but are rather inconsistent and struggle terribly when facing top defenses, which doesn’t bode well for the SEC. He does seem to be a heck of a recruiter and a player favorite, though.
I found this at one of the many, many threads bashing Watson over at huskerboard. The rankings are the Big 12 offensive rankings:
2000 (Colorado): 8th, 362.0 YPG
2001 (Colorado): 2nd, 434.4 YPG
2002 (Colorado): 9th, 374.5 YPG
2003 (Colorado): 9th, 372.6 YPG
2004 (Colorado): 9th, 339.6 YPG
2005 (Colorado): 8th, 333.1 YPG
2008 (Nebraska): 6th, 450.8 YPG
2009 (Nebraska): 11th, 332.8 YPG
2010 (Nebraska): 6th, 414.2 YPG
Outside of 2001 and 2008 his offenses have really been pretty mediocre.
If they’re going to hire an OC as a HC, then I’d much rather see Vandy pull in someone like Malzahn or Chryst, whose offenses have at least been consistently great.
What about some pro names?
Josh McDaniels just got fired. Could he be a potential hire? I also heard Herman Edwards announce a game for Vandy. Could he be a target? There are a lot of pro coordinators that I have a lot of respect for, could any pro coordinators be a potential target?
Herm and McDaniels could be great recruiters and possibly great coaches with the right staff.
LOL
Not busting on your suggestions, just get a kick out of the idea of McDaniels going to Denver, running Cutler out of town, getting fired, then going to Cutler’s alma mater. That would be a riot. I don’t like McDaniels though. Seems like a tool.
I can also just imagine the Herm-Vandy jokes. “YOU PLAY TO WIN A GAME.” Haha. Oh, Herm is funny. Our records, are not.
Temple and Al Golden
Temple goes 8-4 and gets DENIED a bowl bid. They beat BCS bowl bound UConn by two TDs and are going to be staying home this December. That’s gotta hurt.
Hey coaches, did we mention the SEC has 10 teams going bowling?
An insider's perspective on Franklin
Hey, all. I’m the lead blogger over Testudo Times, SBN’s MD blog (just so you understand my perspective). Just figured I’d give a quick note about Franklin, just as an FYI:
Most fans at Maryland (and, to be honest, Ralph Friedgen himself) don’t like Franklin. It’s safe to say that the majority of fans would be happy if Frank left. He’s had waaaaay too many “WTF?” playcalls and has overseen too many awful offenses for anyone involved with the program to have a positive opinion of him. Maryland hasn’t had an innovative, successful offense in years. Part of that is Friedgen, but Franklin’s inability to use any measure of innovation in playcalling is a big reason they’ve been so bad the past few years.
That said, he has some qualities that should make him a decent HC, which is probably the only reason we haven’t torn up his HCIW deal, paid him the million dollar buyout, and told him to GTFO. He’s a good motivator and communicator, from what I’ve read. He’s also a really good recruiter that managed to steal some gems last year despite MD going 2-10. And, like many new young coaches, he can sell the program. He’s also apparently rather personable and a very good interviewee, which means it might get interesting if he gets a callback. (He’s also ambitious, so he’ll more than likely leave Vandy if he has success and a bigger name comes calling).
Still can’t call plays worth a damn. If he wants some measure of control offensively, you’re probably in trouble. If not, he really does have potential, as much as I hate to admit it. Basically, he’s going to be at his best as a program CEO with really good coordinators. Anything else, and…meh. Not sure if that gets you excited and it’s definitely a gamble, but I wouldn’t really be shocked if had success as a HC after basically failing as an OC.
Thanks for the info. Not sure where he is on the list right now but I know they’re in the process of whittling it down.
He may or may not be interested in Vandy or vice versa, but you should either hear him reaffirm his commitment to Maryland or it start to leak out that he’s a serious candidate perhaps over the next 24 hours.
Lockridge says we're getting closer with some good quotes from the Athletic Chancellor
BTW, how can the media think we’re at a disadvantage because we have no athletic director. WE’VE GOT AN ATHLETIC CHANCELLOR! Chancellor ranks above Director. Look at Germany? If they only had a director instead of Chancellor Angela Merkel would they be the leading economy in the EU? I think NOT!
ANYWAY,
Locky confirms in his latest that we have contacted basically all the names we’ve heard here.
Tulsa Coach Todd Graham, Nebraska offensive coordinator Shawn Watson, Maryland offensive coordinator James Franklin, Michigan State offensive coordinator Don Treadwell and Wisconsin defensive coordinator Dave Doeren.
Stanford assistant head coach/offense coordinator Greg Roman interviewed in person Friday. Vanderbilt also has met with Graham and Treadwell.
He says we are heading towards a final list of 3-4.
Of the names that have popped up in the last few days, the only one he didn’t confirm was Chryst, the Wisconsin OC.
I assume Vanderbilt has “met with” means we have interviewed Graham and Treadwell. Both names that sound solid. I like the Graham/Hand combo.
Treadwell has been a quasi-HC this year with their HC sick. But in his 4 years as OC his scoring offense has been 29, 62, 36, 39 and his total offense has been 42, 74, 38, 39, so it’s not like he’s set the world on fire with his bold ideas.
FootballScoop.com also says we have interviewed Doeren, the Wisconsin DC.
Lockridge says that we really aren’t getting much play with Malzahn or (as we’ve heard before) Golden.
He also says we like the AF head coach Calhoun, and that we’ll interview him if he is interested. But word on Twitter today was that Calhoun actually turned down a shot at the Broncos (a slightly more prestigious and lucrative position) to stay at Air Force.
Possibly interesting, no mention of Foster, Bowden or Shannon as people who have or will interview. I don’t think this is a complete list by any means, but the longer it goes without hearing that they’ve interviewed, the less likely they seem.
Also, we haven’t heard anything on Whipple or Lee at any point, so it seems they aren’t likely in the mix. And no mention of Jasper since the early days, so that’s probably history.
I quite enjoyed the AC DW quotes in this one. He basically says, that they are asking a lot of questions about who an offensive minded HC would have leading the defense and who a defensive minded HC would have leading the offense.
DW:
I think the question (we’ve) asked is: ’Who’s going to run the offense and who’s going to run the defense?’
If it’s an offensive person, we’re a little more interested in what’s going to be happening with the defense. If it’s a defensive person, we’re a little more interested in what’s going to be happening with the offense. The fact more offensive persons have been identified as targets is just how it’s gone.
I know that DW likes to stay out of telling an HC who to hire for his staff, but I really like that he’s at least considering the kind of staff they’d put together in his decisions. This is especially important to me when you’re talking to assistants who have no experience building staffs.
Another interesting interview with DW
The school paper had a nice interview with DW.
Some high points: he said that the current head coaches are less willing to participate in the formal interview process because they don’t want people to know they’re on the market. For example, guys like that, they are more prone to go to them for an interview rather than bringing them in.
Makes it seem possible that there is someone out there that we have had more contact with than the media reports would have us believe.
The other interesting thing is that he said he’d ideally like to have a coach in place before the players leave for winter break. That’s next Friday, so we could have a guy in place in the next 10 days.
Great work on the coaching search at Moral Victory
They aren’t our Vandy blogger rivals are they?
Great list of candidates tiered by how possible they are.
And info capsules on some of the coordinators we’ve heard in the last couple days.
Via VSL, Down to 2?
VSL passed on a report from Washington Post.
The Post’s Maryland beat reporter says that Franklin, the Terps’ OC and HCIW is one of two finalists here and that he believes Greg Roman is the other.
The timing for finalists seems like it could be right, so it’s possible.
If this is the case, I vote Roman.
I’d be concerned about Franklin, I just can’t see making a big difference in terms of excitement with, “Look at all I accomplished at Maryland.”
But if his coordinators looked OK, I’d be open-minded I think (though I can’t promise my immediate reaction wouldn’t be somewhat more visceral and maybe more negative).
Vandy interested in Navy Head Coach Ken Niumatalolo
Jeff Lockridge gives an update on the coach search this morning and states Navy HC Ken Niumatalolo is in the mix for the job. That’s the first I’ve heard his name, but apparently Vandy is very interested:
“Vanderbilt is interested in Navy Coach Ken Niumatalolo and ideally wants to speak with him about the school’s football vacancy before its second round of interviews, a source says.
However, Niumatalolo will not entertain any talks until after Saturday’s Army-Navy game, the source said. Niumatalolo is 26-13 at Navy in his third full season since taking over when Paul Johnson left for Georgia Tech."
I was surprised not to see this come up before. He was everyone’s ideal target 4 months ago, then we heard nothing about him until now.
Navy beat blog says he's not interested
Not shocking for them to say that. It’s not totally conclusive, but he seemed like a long shot anyway.
BTW, a little strong worded there “The Capital.” Vanderbilt Report Off-Base? Seriously? Wasn’t the report that we wanted to talk to him to see if he would be interested?
Confirmed by Lockridge
http://blogs.tennessean.com/vanderbilt/2010/12/09/navys-niumatalolo-a-long-shot-at-best/
With him mostly out of the picture, I’d bet DW will be getting into finalist interviews real quick. I wouldn’t be shocked to see a hire even before the weekend, though maybe Sunday or early next week would be my bet.
west coast vs pro-style vs option
So, it could be Roman’s pro-style offense, Franklin’s west coast offense or Niumatalolo’s option (if he’s interested) or even someone else….talk about going in any number of directions.
I'm really impressed with the work Zep and Dave are putting in on this.
(I call them Zep and Dave, I feel we’ve grown close over the last two weeks).
I think they are doing a great job and I hope they get a great coach out of it.
They are not limiting themselves to offensive coaches, or to a certain system. They are considering what kind of staff the coach would build. They want to be convinced that the new coach is a good Xs and Os schemer, but without really caring what the scheme actually is.
I get the idea that rather than scheme, they are looking for fit, in terms of someone who has the vision for the team that they have and is realistic about how to get there.
I think they have also done a really good job of keeping the press out of it. We have names and guesses as to who they like most, but no real idea where they stand in the process beyond our guesses on terms of timetable.
I think they have also done a great job of hiding any possible surprise hire. I’d bet money that they are spending at least part of their time on a really big name that they believe they have some small, but realistic shot at.
I’m not saying we’ll end up with a big surprise hire, but I’m pretty confident that whoever we end up with (still betting on Roman), that we will have taken a few big shots along the way.
For what its worth...
http://voices.washingtonpost.com/hokies-journal/2010/12/foster_turned_down_an_intervie.html
Foster: " I don’t know how I would do with the best you can do is win five or six games if you play your best football."
Well thats certainly not the attitude of a coach we want going forward. Guess thats why they start out with a lot of candidates.

by 




















